Is PokeMagic trustworthy? Reviews and trustmark

Rens Slot

12/14/2025

My order arrived in poor condition. One card was supposed to be in its original plastic packaging, but it was in a repacked plastic bag. There was damage to my other Pikachu card that was supposed to be new. Additionally, my other sleeved card that was in the package is not in good condition and has very poor centering. I paid a lot of money for these!

Translated with AI

Job
12/30/2025
No response to my request for an invoice. In the end, I was helped well.
Translated with AI
Rens Slot
12/14/2025
My order arrived in poor condition. One card was supposed to be in its original plastic packaging, but it was in a repacked plastic bag. There was damage to my other Pikachu card that was supposed to be new. Additionally, my other sleeved card that was in the package is not in good condition and has very poor centering. I paid a lot of money for these!
Translated with AI
Response by PokeMagic
Hello Rens, The Celebi card you mentioned was not listed as sealed on the site. The card was sold as a single card in "Good" condition. This is a commonly used term in the TCG world and indicates that the card has visible signs of wear but is not severely damaged. Centering is not a factor in determining the condition of single cards (not graded). The condition is purely based on damage to the card. The price of this card in Excellent/Near Mint condition is significantly higher (double the amount paid) as we adjust our prices according to the condition of the card as stated on the site. The sealed cards were not damaged during shipping. Since this notification comes quite late (3+ weeks after shipping), we will need to see if we can still contact the transport company regarding this, as any damage would have had to occur during transport.
Translated with AI
How would you rate PokeMagic?
Just van Stralen
12/12/2025
Ricardo
12/11/2025
Always nice to receive a package from PokéMagic. You can be sure that everything is right and the quality (and price!) is fantastic. Thank you for the great service! (:
Translated with AI
Mike Blauwers
12/10/2025
Great!
Translated with AI
Nicolas Schrama
12/8/2025
Perfect
Translated with AI

PokeMagic

Average score

Calculation of the score

External sources

Average score

Calculation of the score

External sources

Last 12 months review count

Approved

ValuedShops reviews

How would you rate PokeMagic?